- Auto Insurance
- /
- New York Auto Insurance
- /
- Auto Insurance in Suffolk County
- /
- Fire Island Auto Insurance
Cheap Auto Insurance in Fire Island, New York
Complete list of all auto insurance companies in Fire Island, NY that provide cheap car insurance in Fire Island. Get online quotes from best auto insurance providers in Fire Island. Compare coverage options and prices.

Nationwide
Nationwide provides cheap auto insurance in Fire Island, NY and makes a smart option for budget-conscious Fire Island car insurance shoppers. Nationwide is a great choice for people who are searching for insurance for a new car as well as those who consider a cheaper auto insurance.
Get a quote
Travelers
Travelers is a cheap car insurance provider in Fire Island, NY. Examples of the car insurance options provided by Travelers include accident forgiveness, affordable premiums, uninsured motorist coverage, collision coverage and rental reimbursement coverage.
Get a quote
Aipso
Aipso provides auto insurance in Fire Island, NY. Aipso offers sensible coverage options such as liability coverage that includes protection, coverage for light or serious injury resulting from an at fault auto accident. There are different types of coverage that offer collision and comprehensive coverages and other coverages. Examples include roadside services like tire changes. This car insurance company offers numerous convenience options that include both phone and online claim system, student discounts, good driver discount and more.
Get a quote
Pure
Pure is an auto insurance company in Fire Island, NY that provides many coverage options. Some of the options provided by Pure include underinsured motorist damage coverage, coverage of pet injuries, roadside coverage, collision plus comprehensive coverage and medical payments protection.
Get a quote
Aaa
Aaa offers auto insurance in Fire Island, NY. Aaa provides affordable automobile insurance rates and includes many discounts that include: electric car discount, accident forgiveness, rental reimbursement, electronic billing, minor glass repair and mechanical breakdown insurance.
Get a quote
Foremost
Foremost provides inexpensive car insurance coverage in Fire Island, NY. Foremost includes repair of your covered vehicle after an accident has occurred, or, if if the car is not repairable then a new vehicle at no cost other than your deductible. Foremost includes many coverage options like rental reimbursement coverage that covers the cost of renting a car while your vehicle is in the auto shop.
Get a quote
Encompass
Encompass provides car insurance in Fire Island, NY. Encompass provides different types of coverage that include collision coverage, comprehensive coverage, liability coverage that offers bodily injury liability coverage as well as property damage liability coverage, medical payments coverage, uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage that helps to cover expenses related to medical bills and car repairs if you are hit by a driver who doesn’t have car insurance, rental reimbursement coverage, roadside coverage, personal umbrella policy, property protection coverage and more.
Get a quote
Mapfre
Mapfre is an auto insurance company in Fire Island, NY. Benefits include discount for anti-lock breaks, student discounts, EZ pay discount, discounts for new car owners and much more. Mapfre also offers cheap car insurance rates to Fire Island, NY car lessees and owners. Coverage that helps to protect you and your car from uninsured drivers and hit-and-run accidents is available.
Get a quote
Hanover
Hanover specializes in affordable auto insurance in Fire Island, NY. Hanover includes numerous coverage types, like collision coverage, Medical payments coverage, comprehensive coverage, accident forgiveness, new car replacement and more. Hanover is designed for Fire Island residents who want both a low-price auto insurance payment with good coverage.
Get a quote
Mercury
Some of the best car insurance rates in Fire Island, NY are offered by Mercury. Reasonable cost combined with several types of coverage along with extensive experience and sound advise allow Mercury to stand out from the competition. All standard forms of car insurance coverage such as liability, collision, comprehensive, medical payments that include rehabilitation and more.
Get a quoteAuto Insurance near Fire Island, New York
- Auto Insurance in Delhi, NY
- Auto Insurance in Homer, NY
- Auto Insurance in Vista, NY
- Auto Insurance in Hillcrest, NY
- Auto Insurance in Virgil, NY
- Auto Insurance in Macedon, NY
- Auto Insurance in Cohoes, NY
- Auto Insurance in Kings Point, NY
- Auto Insurance in Mechanicville, NY
- Auto Insurance in Vails Gate, NY
- Auto Insurance in Brookville, NY
- Auto Insurance in Springs, NY
- Auto Insurance in Plandome, NY
- Auto Insurance in Crompond, NY
- Auto Insurance in Scranton, NY
- Auto Insurance in Smithtown, NY
- Auto Insurance in Salem, NY
- Auto Insurance in Highland Mills, NY
- Auto Insurance in Schaghticoke, NY
- Auto Insurance in Ellenburg Depot, NY
Find the best auto insurance rate in your area. 100% free service.